by Ryan Beadle
The Wall Street Journal reported today that the IRS will expand a program that searches for inconsistencies between mortgage payments and income.
Under the document matching program, the IRS matches forms it is provided for consistency in income reporting. The most familiar example may be matching an employer-provided Form W-2, with the worker’s Form 1040, to verify the amount of income.
Each year, a third party lender that collects mortgage interest files Form 1098 with the IRS, reporting the receipt of interest income. In theory, if a taxpayer paid mortgage interest, he or she should have had income available to pay it. Based on that assumption, the IRS has routinely checked filed Forms 1098 to identify nonfilers.
Now, the IRS indicated it will begin to match the amount of interest paid, as shown on Form 1098, with the amount of income reported on Form 1040, to identify possible underreporting of income.
The IRS believes this may be a good source of information regarding workers that are paid in cash and underreport their income.
At the same time, many individuals may have lost jobs and dipped into savings in order to continue making their mortgage payments. That group may include both high net worth families and struggling families. Their Forms 1040 will not reflect additional income, so the IRS’s Document Matching Program may trigger a “false positive.”
This serves as a good reminder to every taxpayer to keep accurate and detailed financial records for all information submitted on tax filings with the IRS, in case of an audit. Given that this is a fresh issue that the IRS has only indicated it will move ahead on, we do not yet know what the IRS will ask a taxpayer to produce in his or her defense. A good start may be for taxpayers to keep records, as best they can, which show the flow of money from legitimate sources to pay the interest on their mortgages.